HB1643 Subject Matter Hearing

Testimony of Jennifer Scaife, Executive Director, Correctional Association of New York
Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Good afternoon. My name is Jennifer Scaife. I am the Executive Director of the Correctional Association of New York. Thank you, Chair Cassidy and committee members, for the opportunity to provide testimony at this subject matter hearing on HB 1643 Corrections Ombudsperson.

The Correctional Association of New York—which I will refer to by its acronym, CANY—is a nonprofit organization granted authority by the New York State Legislature in 1846 to carry out what we now refer to as independent prison oversight.

Until relatively recently, CANY operated primarily with private philanthropic support and its authority to provide effective, comprehensive oversight of New York State prisons was constrained by limitations in the law. But events of late 2024 and early 2025 catalyzed several landmark policy reforms and fiscal investments in independent oversight in our state.

In December 2024 and March 2025, two incarcerated men—Robert Brooks and Messiah Nantwi—were murdered by correctional officers in two separate facilities. One of these murders was unwittingly captured on body-worn camera. Adding to this crisis, correctional officers launched a 22-day wildcat strike, which resulted in the declaration of a state of emergency and deployment of the National Guard.

These events followed a period of unrest in the prisons, fueled by chronic understaffing, excessive use of mandatory overtime, resentment among correctional officers about reforms to the prison disciplinary system, and a longstanding, well-documented culture of brutality on the part of corrections staff toward incarcerated people.

In the years leading up to the murders and the wildcat strike, CANY had repeatedly documented allegations of abuse of incarcerated individuals by correctional officers; called for expanded camera coverage; and reported on living and working conditions that undermined the goals of rehabilitation and workplace safety.

The New York State Legislature’s answer to these entrenched challenges was the Prison Reform Omnibus Act. The law built on CANY’s existing access by granting the ability to provide 24 hours advance notice of a monitoring visit to the corrections agency instead of the previous 72 hours. The law codified CANY’s authority to operate a confidential hotline and to correspond with incarcerated individuals under legal privilege. The law also established the requirement that the corrections agency transfer administrative data to CANY on a quarterly basis—data that previously could only be obtained through freedom of information request.

The 2025 state budget also reflected significant new investments aimed at addressing the need for greater scrutiny of prisons. The Governor and the Legislature committed $3 million in new funds during the state budget cycle to support CANY’s oversight activities. This transformational investment doubled the size of the organization’s staff and shifted its budget from primarily privately funded to primarily state funded, overnight. That funding was continued in 2026. For context, New York State’s corrections agency budget in FY 26-27 was $4 billion.

As you have heard from the other panelists, maintaining external oversight of prisons is a necessary precursor to accountability. The role of independent oversight goes beyond the crises I just described in New York to serve broader goals. These include interpreting seemingly opaque operational challenges so that they may be understood and addressed by policymakers who are unfamiliar with the innerworkings of correctional facilities. These goals also include bringing to light conditions that affect both incarcerated people and facility staff so that policymakers are better able to offer solutions that improve outcomes across the system. And independent oversight performs the essential function of monitoring the implementation of policy and reporting back to the Legislature and other stakeholders about progress, or unintended consequences.

Independent oversight is among a state's most cost-effective tools. Illinois would be well served by formally codifying, empowering, and resourcing additional oversight of its prisons.

Thank you for this opportunity to testify. I would be pleased to answer any questions you have.

Next
Next

Public Comment: Proposed Addition of Part 1706 to Title 7 NYCRR - Heat Mitigation Plan I.D. No. CCS-50-25-00001-P