The need for oversight of prisons is
As Urgent Today as it was 175 Years Ago
CANY is the only independent organization in New York with authority under state law to monitor prisons. Our access creates a platform for those most affected by incarceration to shape the public debate.
Today, the Correctional Association of New York (CANY) released a report that highlights widespread distrust
Of the prison-based healthcare system managed by the Department of Corrections and Community Supervision (DOCCS) and offers insight into the drivers of COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among incarcerated people. As of December 23, 2021, only 16,050 or 52.2% of the prison population had accepted at least one dose of the vaccine (compared to roughly 85% of the general population in New York State).
Since the onset of the pandemic, CANY has monitored the impact of COVID-19 on people in prison, including incarcerated people’s access to and attitudes toward vaccinations in prison. CANY conducted monitoring visits to eight prisons between July 2020 and June 2021 and distributed a survey by mail regarding vaccine hesitancy to incarcerated people.
Our findings highlight that vaccine hesitancy is rooted in incarcerated people’s prior negative experiences with the prison healthcare system, a system-wide lack of trust in DOCCS administration and medical staff, and the history of medical experimentation on incarcerated populations. One incarcerated person voiced his hesitancy to be vaccinated this way: “As an incarcerated individual my greatest fear is to be a lab rat for the state.”
In an effort to limit the spread of COVID-19 in state prisons and combat vaccine hesitancy among incarcerated individuals, CANY recommends that the State of New York decarcerate prisons to limit the spread of COVID-19, comprehensively reform access to medical care in prisons, and address substandard care by expanding the Department of Health’s existing power to oversee the administration of health care in prisons.
The COVID-19 pandemic has revealed significant deficiencies and limitations in DOCCS’s ability to limit the spread of illness in prisons, provide adequate medical care, and respond to emergent health crises in prisons. In light of COVID-19 outbreaks at several DOCCS facilities and rising deaths, it is imperative that policymakers implement CANY’s recommendations to improve the health outcomes of incarcerated individuals.