CA Statement on the Apparent Suicide of John MacKenzie
Correctional Association of New York (CA) Statement on the Apparent Suicide of John MacKenzie
(August 8, 2016, New York): The Correctional Association of New York is heartbroken by the apparent suicide of John MacKenzie, and outraged by the continuing cruel vindictiveness of the actions of the New York State Parole Board. The Parole Board continues to destroy people’s lives by repeatedly denying release to men and women who have transformed their lives, demonstrated their readiness to return home, and do not pose a risk to society. Despite public outcries and judges’ admonitions, the Board continues to deny parole based on the nature of their original offense — something that can never change regardless of what they have accomplished or who they are today, or the positive contributions they have and will continue to make. In doing so, the Board thwarts and undermines the very purpose of parole, strips away applicants’ hope, devastates their families, and deprives communities of people who could make positive and meaningful contributions to its well-being.
In his more than 40 years in prison, John MacKenzie transformed himself and touched innumerable people’s lives. He was deeply remorseful for Matthew Giglio, the person’s life he had taken, and decades ago started a victim impact program in honor of Matthew and his family. John earned multiple college degrees while incarcerated, started and led programs, mentored many other incarcerated people, and had a clean disciplinary record for over 35 years. At more than 70 years old, he was a highly skilled jailhouse lawyer and advocate whom many of us at the Correctional Association knew for a long time.
Despite John’s decades-long transformation and growth, and the low risk his State evidence-based risk assessment reflected, the Parole Board repeatedly denied parole release to John, who had already served 16 more years in prison than his minimum sentence. The Board’s latest denial last week was not only counter to logic, reason, and fairness; it was also in defiance of a New York Supreme Court decision. Judge Maria Rosa in October 2015 vacated an earlier denial of John’s parole release, and then in May 2016 found the Board in contempt of court because the Board ignored her decision and denied John parole again solely on the basis of his original offense. In Judge Rosa’s words, “This case begs the question, if parole isn’t granted to this petitioner, when and under what circumstances would it be granted?” The New York Times Editorial Board agreed with Judge Rosa’s assessment and called for the Board’s release of “obviously qualified people like John MacKenzie.”
The judge ordered a new hearing and ordered that none of the commissioners who had been on John’s hearings in 2014 or 2015 participate in the new hearing. Yet, last week, the Parole Board had one of those very same commissioners sit in on John’s hearing and vote to deny parole release yet again.
The Parole Board’s repeated denial of John’s release is hard to be understood as anything other than the infliction of cruelty, vengeance, and perpetual punishment. In John’s case, the result was the tragic loss of his life. Unfortunately, the Board is regularly carrying out this same approach with countless others of repeatedly denying parole based on the nature of a person’s original offense regardless of who the person is today. The Parole Board, along with the Governor and the State of New York, must finally stop this unlawful intransigence and perpetual punishment and must release parole-ready people. In John’s memory and honor, we must all continue the struggle for parole justice and the return home of our fellow community members.
As a follow up to the Correctional Association of New York's statement last month critical of reported plans by New York to severely limit the number of visits by family members to incarcerated loved ones in NY state prisons, in early March the CA wrote directly to Governor Andrew Cuomo to express its opposition to the plan.Read More
Victor Pate spent almost two years in solitary confinement in New York prisons, off and on. Once, he said, he was isolated for 90 days for having too many bed sheets in his room. Only two sheets were allowed per prisoner, but Pate was at his prison job when laundry pickup came, he said, so [...]Read More
Under unique statutory authority granted to the CA in 1846, WIPP monitors conditions in women’s prisons in New York, a role played by no other group in the country. WIPP coordinates the Coalition for Women Prisoners, a statewide alliance of more than 1,800 people, and carries out advocacy campaigns to reform harmful criminal justice policies. [...]Read More
Watch the Correctional Association’s video about the barbaric – and illegal – shackling of incarcerated women during childbirth. In 2009 New York enacted a statute restricting the use of shackles on women during childbirth. The law bans outright the use of restraints on women throughout labor, delivery and recovery “after giving birth,” which is meant [...]Read More